Skip to main content

The Arctic – Emerging opportunities beneath the ice

With global warming gradually melting away polar ice caps, new opportunities are slowly, but surprisingly, emerging for trade, tourism and natural resource extraction in the Arctic Circle. But is developing such opportunities at odds with environmental sustainability?

Arctic sea ice sank to yet another record annual low in September 2012, at 44% below the 1981-2010 average. The Arctic Ocean is projected to be almost ice-free by the end of this century; with the ice melting at an accelerating rate, quicker than predicted by any climate model.

A decade ago, Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth” drew world attention to the moral consequences of global warming. These included the destruction of farming, the flooding of coastal land displacing millions of people and the spread of tropical diseases to new parts of the global population.

Though the consequences of global warming on the Arctic are inherently detrimental, the shrinking icecaps herald new opportunities for trade, tourism and natural resource exploration in the Arctic Circle. The Arctic is expected to become more important in the coming decades, as climate change uncovers hidden natural resources and reveals new transport routes.

In 2012, 46 ships transported a total of 1.3 million tons of cargo using the Northern Sea Route - up from 34 ships and an estimated 820,000 tons in 2011.

In 2012, 46 ships transported a total of 1.3 million tons of cargo using the Northern Sea Route which runs along the northern coast of Russia – up from 34 ships and an estimated 820,000 tons in 2011.

What does the Arctic region offer?
A powerful testament to the interest that the Artic is arousing among the nations of the world was the fierce competition to gain observer status at the Arctic Council. Six new countries were recently granted this status, including China, India, Singapore, Italy, Japan and South Korea.

The council was first established in 1996 to promote co-operation amongst countries with interests in the Arctic. While it is an intergovernmental forum with no decision-making power, it aims to protect the Artic region’s environment.

Why the heightened interest among the nations of the world in the Arctic region?
  • Discovery of shipping routes
New shipping routes would principally translate to greater cost and time savings for cross-continental exports and cargo hauling. When the Arctic ice melted over the summer of 2012, 46 ships from Far Eastern ports used the Northern Sea Route (which runs along the northern coast of Russia) to sail through the icy Arctic to Europe.

European countries have a vested interest in the new shipping route, as it would enable ships to circumnavigate numerous bottlenecks, like the Suez Canal, to increase access to Asia’s rapidly expanding consumer markets and manufacturing centers. It is therefore not surprising that Russia set up the Northern Sea Route administration in March, so as to supervise shipping.
  • Emerging tourist spot
In recent years, Icelandic destinations like Jokulsarion and Hella have become popular tourist spots because of their Northern Lights displays. This is a huge departure from the trickle of extreme adventurer tourists which used to be the region’s mainstay.

Polar tourism caters to tourists looking for unique experiences in the Polar Regions such as wildlife observation, sightseeing, fishing and hunting, not to mention extreme outdoor activities as well as cultural and historical activities.

While this rise in tourism has yielded economic benefits, it has also enhanced global awareness of the culture of the indigenous Arctic communities.

Icelandic destinations like Jokulsarion and Hella have become popular tourist spots because of their Northern Lights displays.
  • Abundant natural resources
The Arctic region could be well on its way to slake the worlds thirst for oil – now running at 86 million barrels of oil consumption per day. This is on account of unexplored oil hidden beneath the ice.

Artic oil has been irretrievable until only recently. Global warming has melted the Arctic ice to such an extent that it propelled oil corporations into a “black gold rush” frenzy. The US Geological Survey (USGS) surmised that approximately 90 billion barrels of undiscovered oil and 1,670 trillion cubic feet of natural gas lie within the Arctic Circle; signifying billions of dollars in revenues. This might account for as much as 20% – 30% of the world’s undiscovered oil and natural gas reserves.

In addition to oil and gas exploration, the warmer water has led to an extension of fish stocks such as capelin and cod in the melting Arctic Ocean. This might lead to massive growth for commercial fisheries.

Zones of conflict
Amidst the mad scramble to grab a piece of the Arctic pie, challenges remain.
  • Environment
As the Arctic ice continues to disappear, indigenous people and species are facing the prospect of endangerment. The Artic is home to 4 million indigenous inhabitants spanning across 30 tribes who have lived there for thousands of years. Their livelihood could possibly be threatened by global economic interests.

An estimated 1.1 million square miles of Arctic waters are unregulated, and this could lead to overfishing. This might lay waste to the fragile Arctic ecosystem and affect sea mammals, such as whales and polar bears.

Major oil spills due to industrial oil drilling would cause extensive damage to marine life and prove difficult to clean up due to the harsh environment conditions; akin to BP’s Deepwater Horizon drilling platform explosion in 2010. That episode caused an environmental disaster and resulted in over 200 million gallons of oil spreading into the Gulf of Mexico. It is still taking a toll on the fishermen since the oyster population – which accounts for about two-thirds of American supply – has been declining since then.

  • Possibility of political conflict
Under International Law, no country has the ownership of the North Pole. However, eight neighbouring countries (U.S., Canada, Denmark, Russia, Norway, Finland, Sweden and Iceland) are keen to stake out unclaimed territories and take advantage of the region’s vast resources, as shown in Image 2. Rivalry for the black gold lying under the Arctic has made it a
burgeoning priority to maintain stability and prevent maritime crime.

Russia has plans to upgrade its northern fleet and train military troops specifically for Arctic warfare, whereas the US plans to position armed coastguard vessels in its Arctic waters. Canada intends to further strengthen its Arctic fleet by building 28 ships with a capital outlay of USD33 billion over the next 30 years.

the Arctic region opens up to economic activity, there is a growing chance that military rivalry will accidentally tip over into armed conflict.

What lies ahead?
As global warming and the melting of the Arctic ice accelerates, tremendous economic opportunities beckon in terms of natural resource extraction, fishing, shipping and tourism. However, equally great are the dangers of irreversible environmental degradation, damage to indigenous peoples as well as political conflict.

The discovery of new sea routes would open up shipping shortcuts between Asia and Europe. The loss of Arctic ice would make commercial fishing feasible, while the unexplored billions of dollars’ worth of oil and gas will inevitably be tapped for human use. Coupled with a rise in mass tourism, the region is definitely poised for economic growth.

The Arctic is thus emerging as the world’s most important test case for whether the current multi-polar world order can successfully engineer peaceful and sustainable co-operation in the pursuit of economic goals.

The development of the tourism industry should be made a key priority by all political players with a stake in the Artic game.
In particular, trans-boundary tourism should be fostered. This is because the tourist industry will provide a strong incentive and nudge for global powers to maintain peaceful and environmentally sustainable economic development in the Arctic region. The Arctic should never be allowed to become a desolate military-dominated no-man’s wasteland akin to the high-altitude glaciers that divide China and India.

A thriving tourism industry – perhaps drawing in the legions of Asian tourists eager to see the Northern Lights, reindeer and polar bears – will stand as a bulwark, making the prospect of a peaceful and prosperous Arctic that much more likely.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

China’s New Silk Road Initiative – An integrated trade strategy for the 21st century?

The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), announced in 2013, is not only China’s most ambitious global infrastructure project but also one of the largest ever attempted anywhere. It aims to develop a free trade zone and improve global connectivity across the Eurasian landmass. With an estimated investment of USD4 to 8 trillion and affecting over 70 countries, can China successfully connect all these economies together? What is China’s BRI? The BRI mega infrastructure project aims to cement links with Southeast Asia, Central Asia, Russia and the Baltic Region. It aspires to establish a free trade zone through infrastructure developments among countries and continents. The idea of the BRI was inspired by the ancient trade routes used by Chinese traders to boost connectivity with not only neighboring nations but with distant countries as well, such as the Roman Empire. Pan-Eurasian trade routes were opened in 130 B.C. during China’s Han Dynasty, ostensibly for international tr...

The Philippines - Asia's next economic powerhouse

The Philippines is emerging as one of Asia’s most dynamic economies, with a forecasted growth rate of 6.9 per cent in 2018 driven by investment and private consumption. The economy recorded growth of over 6 per cent in 2017, for the sixth straight year, thanks to buoyant government spending, exports and a recovery in the agricultural sector. Will this Southeast Asian tiger be able to maintain its momentum? A growing economy While advanced economies like the United States, Europe and Japan are growing at slow rate, a number of emerging economies like the Philippines continue to surge ahead. With annual growth expected to reach 6.9 per cent by 2018, the Philippines now ranks as the 10th fastest growing economy globally. Owing to strong domestic demand and government projects, the country’s economy is on the rise. The government’s expansionary fiscal policy has aided capital formation and credit growth, whereas low inflation has strengthened private consumption. Path...

Ethiopia’s Strategic Cooperation with China

Over the past decade, Ethiopia has experienced an average economic growth rate of about 10%. Ethiopia is expected to grow by 8.5% in 2018, topping China’s projected growth of 6.5%. In recent times, the Ethiopian government has abandoned its 1970’s Communist ideology and put in place some basic reforms. They went on to build sturdy infrastructure and launch a successful industrial policy, calling to mind China’s own development pathway. The Chinese have contributed significantly to the building of Ethiopian infrastructure, with rail systems, buildings and dams. Will Ethiopia succeed in copying China’s development model? Read here more:  https://www.spireresearch.com/newsroom/spirethoughts/ethiopias-strategic-cooperation-with-china/

Ghana citizenships to boost economy

In November 2019, 126 African-Americans and Afro-Caribbean’s were granted citizenship, in a ceremony that marks 2019 as the Year of Return. 500,000 tourists are expected to visit Ghana during the Year of Return, a considerable increase from the 380,000 that visited in 2018. Visa on arrival for some and waive off of Visa charges have been introduced. The government also plans to invest in educated returnees to help boost the economy through employment. Is investment in human capital the way to boost Ghana’s economy? Read more:  https://www.spireresearch.com/newsroom/spirethoughts/ghana-citizenships-to-boost-economy/

Is a Korean peace treaty on the cards?

The historical and unprecedented meeting between the two leaders of Korea is a monumental development. Can both leaders use this opportunity enhance geo-political stability and open up new economic development possibilities? Leon Perera, CEO of Spire Research and Consulting, shared his thoughts in The Business Times – Views from the Top section on 7 May 2018. Marking a remarkable change, the unprecedented meeting between the leaders of the two Koreas underlines the possibility of a peace treaty and denuclearization agreement. However, Perera expressed scepticism about North Korea’s commitment to completely renounce nuclear strike capability against Japan and South Korea, since this is the only factor ensuring regime survival. World leaders need to take this chance to limit the North’s nuclear capability while accepting that it may never be completely voided, bring the North into the global framework and work towards economic development on the Korean peninsula. Read...